Using a Gulf of Mexico Atlantis Model to Evaluate Ecological Indicators for Sensitivity to Fishing Mortality and Robustness to Observation Error
Atlantis, Ecosystem-based fisheries management (EBFM), Gulf of Mexico, Fishing effects
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
This work provides a formal evaluation of 25 ecological indicators highlighted by the Southeast Fisheries Science Center’s IEA program as useful for tracking ecosystem components in the Gulf of Mexico. Using an Atlantis ecosystem model as an operating model, we select indicators that are quantifiable using simulation outputs and evaluate their sensitivity to changes in fishing mortality. Indicator behavior was examined using a multivariate ordination. The ordination is used to tell how well each indicator describes variation in ecosystem structure (termed ‘importance’) under different levels of fishing mortality and to reveal redundancies in the information conveyed by indicators. We determine importance using sample data from the operating model, with and without observation error added. Indicators whose importance is diminished least by error are considered robust to observational error. We then quantify the interannual noise of each indicator, where annual variability relates to the required sampling frequency in a management application. Red snapper biomass, King mackerel biomass and Reef fish catch ranked in the top 5 most important without error scenarios, and King mackerel biomass and Species richness were in the top 5 most important even after error was added. Red snapper biomass was consistently found to be the most important and most robust among fishing mortality scenarios tested, and all 4 of these indicators were found to have low levels of interannual noise suggesting that they need to be sampled infrequently. Our results provide insight into the usefulness of these indicators for fisheries managers interested in the impacts of fishing on the ecosystem.
Was this content written or created while at USF?
Citation / Publisher Attribution
Ecological Indicators, v. 74, p. 516-525
Scholar Commons Citation
Masi, M. D., "Using a Gulf of Mexico Atlantis Model to Evaluate Ecological Indicators for Sensitivity to Fishing Mortality and Robustness to Observation Error" (2017). C-IMAGE Publications. 42.